Reading ontheweb

New 09.04.03

Approach - Avoidance

Dividing Line

Dan is a former colleague of Nancy's who writes an occasional column for the Northfield News and commutes to Minneapolis. His unflagging optimism reminds of my former colleague, Dan Eckberg. You all should be so lucky to know both of these guys. The Jorgenson Dan wrote recently.



" I wanted to send in a couple of comments about White Oleander, a 1999 book by Janet Fitch that also became a movie in 2002. After the movie came out, I decided that before seeing it I should first read the book because some key elements of the story are not translated very well onto the big screen.

"This was selected by Oprah's Book Club (when that was still going) and rightfully so. However, it's not for the faint of heart if you are left gasping by abusive situations.

"The story is told from the viewpoint of Astrid -- a young girl who is thrust into said abusive situations. This is one of those books that repulses you with its graphic descriptions of her abuse while at the same time drawing you along because of the intensity of the story and the intriguing and often gut-wrenching relationship between Astrid and her mother.

"Set in southern California, the story follows Astrid and her mother over a six-year period. Astrid ages from 12 to 18. During that time, her mother is jailed for murder and Astrid is shuttled from one foster home to another where varying forms of abuse -- some of it brought on by her own actions -- occurs.

"We watch a fairly innocent young girl turn into a hardened young adult whose relationship with her mother is maintained through an exchange of letters and occasional visits to the prison in which she is housed.

"Astrid goes from grief over her mother's incarceration to anger and then hatred before ultimately coming to grips with who her mother is and why things turned out as they did. She also decides that while she can never fully forgive, she can understand how and why her mother's life spiraled out of control and left her child in harm's way.

"This is a fascinating book but be prepared for some very intense and hard-hitting writing that makes you wonder 'who's in charge here?' in regard to a foster care system that 'throws away' kids in this way.

"One of the jacket blurbs on this book says 'The narrator is particularly memorable -- there were times she made me want to cheer and weep simultaneously.' Me, too. I highly recommend it.

"Just one more thing about White Oleander. I probably should explain the book's title. The oleander is a flowering tree or shrub that is beautiful to see but poisonous to those who come in contact with it. This is a good representation of Astrid's mother, who also, not incidentally, chooses to make a poisonous concoction from the Oleander to kill her victim."


Thank you, Dan. You have made me want to read the book. And the movie? Did you see that? Anyone else want to add a movie review?

Write Tell a little bit of the world what you think.

Reading Home Page | Recent Additions Page

Dividing Line

By Ken Wedding. 09.01.02 Updated 09.06.03.
Credit to Macintosh Spun with PageSpinner